How Much Is Pyrex Butterprint Worth to Resell?

Pyrex Butterprint is the most sought-after pattern in Pyrex collecting. The turquoise print on white or white on turquoise commands top dollar.

💰 Current Resale Prices (2026)

Butterprint 4-Piece Nesting Bowl Set$65–$180

Complete set of 4 is worth 3x the value of 4 individual bowls.

Butterprint Casserole 2qt$20–$55

With lid adds $10-15 to value.

Butterprint Cinderella Bowl 441$25–$70

Largest Cinderella bowl most sought after individually.

Butterprint Refrigerator Dish Set$35–$90

Blue print on white most rare.

Max Price to Pay at Thrift Store

$18

Full Butterprint nesting bowl set for $10 at Goodwill sells for $120-160 on Etsy — about $125 profit.

⚠️ Watch Out For

Pattern on outside fades with dishwasher use — hold up to light to check. Chips anywhere on pattern are visible and reduce value 60%.

Butterprint features a rooster and wheat/corn print. Produced from 1957-1968. Pattern name is stamped on the bottom of the piece.

White print on turquoise (reverse Butterprint) is rarer and worth 20-30% more than the standard turquoise print on white.

Scan Any Item Instantly

Point your camera at any thrift store item and get exact resale prices, fees, and profit in seconds.

Android coming soon