How Much Is McCoy Pottery Worth to Resell?
McCoy pottery is one of the most profitable antique categories. Cookie jars especially fetch extraordinary prices from collectors.
💰 Current Resale Prices (2026)
McCoy Cookie Jar Mammy$80–$300
Most valuable McCoy cookie jar.
McCoy Thinking Bear Cookie Jar$60–$180
Bear and Hobby Horse most popular after Mammy.
McCoy Planter Vintage$15–$65
Animal and figural planters most sought after.
McCoy Vase$20–$80
Matte glaze pre-1960s commands premium.
Max Price to Pay at Thrift Store
$20
McCoy Mammy cookie jar for $8 at Goodwill sells for $120-180 on eBay — about $140 profit.
⚠️ Watch Out For
McCoy reproductions exist especially for cookie jars. Check bottom marks carefully.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I identify authentic McCoy pottery?
Look for USA mark on the bottom. McCoy name in block letters appears on most pieces after 1940.
Scan Any Item Instantly
Point your camera at any thrift store item and get exact resale prices, fees, and profit in seconds.
Download Free on iOS →Android coming soon