How Much Are Magic The Gathering Cards Worth?

Magic: The Gathering has some of the most valuable individual cards ever printed. The Power 9 from 1993 are worth thousands each.

💰 Current Resale Prices (2026)

Black Lotus Alpha/Beta$10000–$500000

Most valuable Magic card ever. Professional authentication required.

Underground Sea Original Dual Land$400–$1200

Original dual lands from 1993-1994 always in demand.

Revised Dual Lands$60–$250

Revised (1994) dual lands much more common but still valuable.

Reserved List Cards$20–$500

Reserved list cards cannot be reprinted — check the list.

Modern Staple Rares$5–$50

Competitive cards change value based on tournament meta.

Max Price to Pay at Thrift Store

Original dual land Underground Sea for $2 at estate sale sells for $600-800 on eBay — the ultimate Magic find.

⚠️ Watch Out For

Fake Magic cards are common for high value cards. Check the font rosette pattern under magnification. Rose Hulman test with light.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I identify valuable old Magic cards?

Check the set symbol (no symbol means Alpha/Beta/Unlimited from 1993). Look up on MTGGoldfish or TCGPlayer. Reserved list cards can never be reprinted.

Where do I sell Magic cards?

TCGPlayer for individual cards. Card Kingdom offers buylist prices for bulk. eBay for Alpha/Beta/Reserved List cards that command collector premiums.

Scan Any Item Instantly

Point your camera at any thrift store item and get exact resale prices, fees, and profit in seconds.

Download Free on iOS →

Android coming soon

← View All Resale Value Guides